Curious – Mind Brain Machine: Unethical Neuroscience

Mind Brain Machine Curious

PBS is airing a program called “Curious” which is described as:

CURIOUS immerses viewers into a fascinating world where science touches people’s lives. Two one-hour episodes profile the innovative men and women pushing the limits of knowledge and applying cutting-edge science to improve lives. Short, character-driven segments combine verite storytelling with stylized visualizations, graphics and animations designed to engage both viewers’ intellect and emotions. These moving, human, funny and sometimes strange stories connect science to real life: a personal crisis inspires a hunt for a cancer cure; artificial eyes restore sight to a blind woman; people learn to function without the use of large parts of their brain and engineers race to find a clean, sustainable fuel for the next century and beyond.

In the “Mind Brain Machine” segment, some of the neuroscientists created a scenario for volunteers where they had to make decisions about how to allocate meals to a group of poor children in Africa.

For example the participants could give 4 meals to each of two children or they could give 10 meals to one child. The neuroscientists told the participants that whatever they decided would actually come to pass.

Giving as it turned out was most gratifying for the participants. And the neuroscientists were able to measure the parts of the brain where the gratification of giving could be measured.

And the experiment should have ended at that point.

But then the neuroscientists changed the experiment and commanded the participants to take meals away from the poor children much in the same way as meals were given in the earlier part of the experiment. For example, the participants had to decide to take away 3 meals from two poverty stricken children or take away 5 meals from one child.

The neuroscientists explained the reason for this experiment was to measure blood flow to different parts of the brain as the participants proceeded during the different stages of the experiment.

The disclaimer at the end of the program read that the participants in the experiment donated over 11,000 meals to these children from some “Caanan school”. This is supposed to justify the experiment.

We believe that to play with people’s lifes like this in the name of science is truly disturbing and unethical.

Taking food away from poor children is absolutely insane.

It makes you wonder about the mental state of the neuroscientists themselves. Perhaps though they actually have a functioning brain, but are so focused on studying the mind (at all costs), that they have lost their heart and soul.

Either way, the neuroscientists that conducted the experiment could have taken a few moments longer to dream up an experiment that would have better accomplished their goals of the program without crossing the ethical line.

The neuroscientists bragged that no one had ever walked out of one of their experiments. However the neuroscientists failed to make the connection, when at least one participant simply stopped making choices toward the end. And complained that the decisions were “too hard” to make. Perhaps a nice way of saying “this is wrong”.

Perhaps the fat-cat psychologists may one-day find themselves deathly hungry only to have an irresponsible party ration or withhold food from them.

There is enough food in the world. And there is no reason for anyone to starve. PBS bears some responsibility for sponsoring programming like this “Curious” episode that exploits the condition of starving children.

French lawmakers OK health care bill targeting anorexia

PARIS Too-thin models, too much drinking, sexy cigarette packs: France's parliament is cracking down on all of these in a sweeping bill designed to improve public health and trim public health costs while tackling unhealthy stereotypes along the way.

Missouri health care navigator law pre-empted, court rules

JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. An appeals court ruled Friday that Missouri can't limit health insurance navigators' ability to help people obtain insurance under President Barack Obama's health care law a ruling that advocates say could have implications for other states that have instituted similar restrictions.

Health system thinker returns to New Zealand

Professor Martin McKee from the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine will address senior medical and dental staff in three district health boards next week.

Health law bumps up tax refunds for some; others take hit

WASHINGTON As the April 15 tax deadline nears, people who got help paying for health insurance under President Barack Obama's law are seeing the direct effect on their refunds hundreds of dollars, for better or worse.

Study: NYC health workers' ethics are compromised in jails

NEW YORK New York City jail health workers say their medical ethics are often compromised by the demands of treating patients who are also prisoners, such as when they witness guards' use of force or are asked to approve stints in solitary confinement, according to a first-of-its-kind city study.

Greece's Tsipras aims to bolster public health care

ATHENS, Greece Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras said Thursday his government will bolster public health care in Greece through the hiring of 4,500 specialized staff and the abolition of a compulsory 5-euro fee for treatment at public hospitals.

Colleges getting out of health insurance business

SEATTLE The federal health care overhaul is leading some colleges and universities to get out of the health insurance business.

Mental health vetting of pilots ineffective, US experts say

WASHINGTON There is little effective, real-world screening of airline pilots for mental problems despite regulations in the U.S., Europe and elsewhere that say mental health should be part of their regular medical exams, pilots and safety experts said.

Indiana to declare public health emergency over HIV outbreak

SCOTTSBURG, Ind. Faced with a growing HIV outbreak tied to intravenous drug use, Indiana Gov. Mike Pence said Wednesday he's considering a needle-exchange program as part of a public health emergency he's preparing to declare in a county that's at the epicenter of the cases.

Fed war on health care spending abuse needs to include Medicare Advantage

Commentary: feds say they're catching health care crooks, but Center reporting showed that Medicare Advantage avoided scrutiny